Although the news coming out of Chicago will probably be the biggest across the NFL today, the Colts have identified their next defensive coordinator. Lou Anarumo is the pick, according to ESPN.com’s Adam Schefter.
Anarumo and Dennis Allen had been discussing the possibility of joining Ben Johnson wherever he landed, The Athletic’s Dianna Russini adds. While the new Bears HC is expected to choose Allen to be his top defensive assistant, Anarumo will make an early jump to Indianapolis. Allen was also a Colts interviewee.
The Chicago component here helps explain why Indianapolis moved so quickly with Anarumo. But the former HC candidate figured to have more options as soon as other teams hired coaches. The ex-Bengals defensive boss had already met with the Falcons about their vacancy, but Atlanta went with Jets interim HC Jeff Ulbrich. That cleared a path for the Colts, who will replace Gus Bradley with another DC with considerable experience in the role.
Anarumo, 58, had devised a plan to cool off Patrick Mahomes and a then-elite Chiefs offense to help the Bengals to an upset in the 2021 AFC championship game. While he was unable to match that feat in the teams’ rematch a year later, the Bengals had entered the 2022 AFC title game ranked sixth in scoring defense. This came after the team went toe-to-toe with the Rams in Super Bowl LVI. Not too many HC looks emerged, however, as Anarumo only met with the Giants (2022) and Cardinals (2023). The Colts had passed on such a meeting, but they will pair Anarumo with Shane Steichen after Bradley’s defense had become somewhat stale.
After Matt Eberflus had engineered three top-10 defensive finishes in his four seasons, Bradley had seen his troops rank 28th, 28th and 24th in points allowed during his three seasons at the helm. The former Jaguars HC and four-time DC coached a similar cast from 2023-24, with GM Chris Ballard continuing to focus on retaining players rather than pursuing outside help. The results did not produce success, potentially leading to a philosophical shift. Bradley’s unit bottomed out in Week 17, when a 45-point outing from a basement-level Giants team eliminated the Colts from playoff contention.
While Anarumo is also coming off a down season (25th in point and yardage), as the Bengals’ defense effectively kept an MVP-caliber Joe Burrow season from even producing a wild-card berth, he has been a well-regarded option for a while. Anarumo spent more than 20 years in the college ranks but has now been an NFL assistant for 13 years. He coached Dolphins DBs under Joe Philbin and Adam Gase, moving to the Giants for a one-year tenure as their secondary coach in 2018. The Colts will sign off on a quick second chance as a DC, keeping one of the higher-profile options off the market for the five teams that still need to hire HCs.
Via PFR’s Offensive/Defensive Coordinator Search Tracker, here is how Indy’s process concluded:
- Dennis Allen, former head coach (New Orleans Saints): Interviewed 1/17
- Lou Anarumo, former defensive coordinator (Cincinnati Bengals): Hired
- Ephraim Banda, safeties coach (Cleveland Browns): Interviewed 1/10
- Wink Martindale, defensive coordinator (Michigan): Interviewed 1/15
- Steve Wilks, former defensive coordinator (San Francisco 49ers): Interviewed