Ryan Kelly has spent his entire career with the Colts, but his next deal may very well come from a different team. The veteran center recently confirmed he will test the open market this spring. 
“Never been a free agent,” Kelly said (via Mike Chappell of Fox59), “so I’m excited to see what’s out there. My plan is to see what’s out there on the market. Indy can always match it. I’ll miss it, if that’s it. It was a good run for nine years.”
Kelly, 31, has started all 121 of his appearances with Indianapolis, providing the team with a consistent presence in the middle over that span. The four-time Pro Bowler made it clear after the end of the 2024 season that his preference is to remain with the Colts, although he is aware he will likely need to be on the move in March. Indianapolis did not include Kelly in the team’s long list of in-house players who were extended or re-signed last offseason, a strong sign a 2025 departure will take place.
The Colts selected a potential Kelly replacement in the form of Tanor Bortolini during last year’s draft. The Wisconsin product made 12 appearances and five starts as a rookie, filling in at center when Kelly missed time with a knee injury. Bortolini could serve as a cost-effective replacement for Kelly over the remainder of his rookie contract, allowing the Colts to focus on other positions with respect to free agent spending.
Kelly has remained steady in terms of PFF evaluation over the course of his career, ranking in the top 10 amongst qualifying centers three times. The most recent of those occasions was in 2023, so the former first-rounder could generate a notable market in spite of his age. Kelly’s PFF grade from this past season (67) was still good enough for 12th at his position.
The Alabama product landed an extension averaging just over $12.4MM in 2020. Kelly will be hard-pressed to command a similar AAV on a new pact this March (especially if he secures a multi-year commitment), but he will have the opportunity to receive offers from suitors before deciding on a potential Indianapolis departure.